The well-known reality that
generations of Americans have been taught in school is that 102
deeply religious Protestant men, women and children from England
landed at what is now Plymouth, Massachusetts on December 21, 1620.
They were later to be referred to collectively as Pilgrims.
But instead of these
Pilgrims, imagine the same number of Buddhist monks had arrived. Or
perhaps a boatload of Druids came ashore on that cold, miserable
day in December. Envision the last remaining members of that
mysterious “pagan” priesthood, first mentioned in Julius Caesar's
diaries in 55 B.C, standing on the beaches of North America.
Would the original
inhabitants of North America, the Indians, have been treated better?
Would there have been slavery? Would we have learned that we're
merely one part of the natural world around us?Yeah, what if?
As we Americans tear
ourselves apart in 2019, it becomes ever more plausible that seeing
eye to eye or at least “getting along” with each other could
become simply impossible. Yeah, but what if?
The arrival of Europeans or
for that matter our imaginary Buddhist monks, probably meant the
civilizations of North and South America were doomed from the start,
almost from the moment the Spanish conquistadors clanked ashore in
their suits of armor in the fifteenth century, more than 100 years
before our pious Protestants arrived in North America.
It was, however, not because
of European technology---or Christianity, that caused the massive
destruction to the civilization of the first inhabitants of North and
South America. The unstoppable enemy was disease, unwittingly (at
least initially) brought by Europeans, of which the the indigenous
population had no immunity.
Because of individuals like
Jared Diamond (Guns, Germs and Steel), Charles Mann (1491), Nathaniel
Philbrick (Mayflower) and many others, we know, among other things,
that geography matters, a lot. Unlike the early inhabitants in the
Western Hemisphere, Europeans had domesticated animals such as oxen,
cows and pigs that did not exist in North and South America.
Europeans contracted
diseases that jumped from animals to humans and over time they built
up a degree of resistance to them. Columbus, Cortez and other
Europeans traveled with the ultimate weapon—not gunpowder—but
hideous viruses like smallpox, typhus, influenza, diphtheria and
measles. It turned out to be an unimaginable “ethnic cleansing”
of entire societies. It may have been the greatest pandemic in human
history.
While population numbers of
North and South America, just before the arrival of the Spanish in
the late 15th century have been estimated from a low of 8
million to a high of more than a 100 million people, this has been a
subject of controversy and debate for some time. But there appears to
be little doubt that millions could have been killed by Europeans
through disease, slavery, wars and environmental destruction.
It's most likely that no
society that existed in North and South America in 1490 imagined
their world would come crashing down upon them. After all, they knew
from their creation stories that generations of their ancestors had
strolled along the same paths they now walked.
This has been the story of
human history, one group of people supplanting another group or being
absorbed into the new tribe.
Yet, there is something
different possibly happening today. What if there are no humans from
somewhere else to replace anyone. What if there are no more human
sounds, here in the United States or anywhere else. Yeah, but what
if?
No comments:
Post a Comment